Roberto Mancini has let Nedum Onuoha join QPR in this transfer window which could prove to be yet another terrible decision and could come back to haunt him as Craig Bellamy has done so recently.
It is unbelievable that Onuoha who is largely underrated by Mancini has not seen much first team action this season after impressing on loan at Sunderland last season it seemed that he at least deserved a chance, at least as backup. When Vincent Kompany was sent off against Manchester United he must have hoped that the Italian manager would have at least played him in one of the Carling Cup semi finals against Liverpool just to see if he was able to fit into his defence.
But remarkably, Mancini stuck with Stefan Savic who ultimately cost City a place in the final of the competition with two shambolic performances, firstly getting bullied by the out of sorts Andy Carroll. If Carroll was in any type of form he would have destroyed him even more, he won most things in the air and brushed him aside with ease. In the City manager’s defence everyone is allowed a bad game and he may have been nervous because of how big the game was. But then he followed up this performance with another shocker against Tottenham and when he misjudged a simple long ball it allowed Jermain Defoe to score and allowed Spurs back into the game. Fortunately, City won the game with a last minute penalty and he was let off the hook.
In the return leg against Liverpool, Onuoha was once again left out and QPR were in talks with the young defender and therefore this basically signalled the end of his career at the Etihad Stadium. But before the deal was completed Savic had another chance to prove he was good enough for the Premier League or at least a more competent defender than the QPR bound man. But he struggled against the pace of Bellamy and he can’t have been completely confident when his own manager didn’t trust him 100% and changed the formation to five at the back so he had extra cover when he inevitably made a mistake. He was still a liability and got hauled off at halftime which must make the supporters of the league leaders worried as they have spent a lot of money yet they have no decent cover in the heart of their defence which is one of the most important positions on the pitch.
Kolo Toure is passed his best, therefore, the club only have two players that have real quality in this position in Vincent Kompany and Joleon Lescott. Even this is quite surprising as last season there were a lot of question marks over Lescott as he had failed to live up to his price tag.
If Man City do not win the league, I will blame Mancini because everyone can see where they need to improve and it’s not as if they have little money to spend. He needs to buy a centre back sooner rather than later or it could cost him his job. I’m not saying Onuoha could have won them the league but surely he would have played a lot better than an out of depth Savic and an out of form Toure.