Is Aiden McGeady’s future in the Premier League and who would he help improve?

Spartak Moscow winger Aiden McGeady has been linked with a move to the Premier League in the last couple of days because his agent has said that he would consider a move if an offer came in for him.

The former Celtic man has been in Russia since 2010 and has been in good form in recent weeks which has made a lot of clubs notice him once again. When he left Celtic he went off the radar slightly as in the past he has been in a very similar position with many teams wanting his services. He won the Player of the Month award three times whilst at Celtic as well as four Young Player of the Month awards so there is no doubting his qualities.

So would any Premier League teams want him and will they be willing to pay quite a high transfer fee for him? Spartak paid around £9.5 million for the winger so they will want at least that if not more but if the player claims he is not happy in Russia and wants to move back to the UK then their hands may be tied and will have to sell him. But, let’s look at who would be interested in him. First team that comes to mind is Sunderland because Martin O’Neill gave him his chance at Celtic and obviously knows what he can bring to the side. His trickery on the wing would be a very useful asset to most teams and a team like Sunderland who are quick on the counter attack could certainly use him. However, Sunderland do have a lot of wingers currently with James McClean, Seb Larsson and new signing Adam Johnson on the books but Larsson could play inside as a central midfielder and even McGeady could play inside just behind the striker. Yet again though, that would cause problems with Stephane Sessegnon usually playing in that role. If Sunderland want to be genuine contenders for a European place or trophies then I think they need some better players and McGeady would give them a lot of strength in depth.

Next, I think that Aston Villa, if they could afford him should be looking to sign him in January as they do have quite a young side and some of their wingers just haven’t lived up to their potential, in particular, Charles N’Zogbia. With Marc Albrighton and Gabriel Agbonlahor (who I think will definitely be a winger under Paul Lambert) struggling with a few injuries at the moment they do seem a little weak out wide. Barry Bannan is inexperienced so he will not be able to produce his best every week and Brett Holman is new to the league so he may also be inconsistent for the first few weeks. If they brought in McGeady they would have a little extra cutting edge and someone that can do something a little special when the game isn’t going quite right for them which is something I think they lack at the moment.

Finally, a team that may be looking to sign him is Newcastle United because they, like Villa, also lacking that little bit of spark, especially if Hatem Ben Arfa is having an off day. They are another team that doesn’t have many wingers that are going to be able to produce consistently. Jonas Gutierrez always does a solid job but in the attacking third his final ball isn’t the best. Sylvain Marveux has had injury problems and has only started two games in the Premier League so he is a difficult one to judge but then the next option is Gabriel Obertan who has not lived up to his potential at either Manchester United or Newcastle so they should maybe look to get rid of him in January anyway and a perfect replacement would be Aiden McGeady.

Aston Villa sign Australian international Brett Holman from AZ Alkmaar

Aston Villa have made their first signing for next season with Australian Brett Holman joining from Dutch side AZ Alkmaar.

The winger was out of contract in the summer so was allowed to speak to other clubs and the player stated himself that he knew all about Villa’s history and this is why he wanted to join the club. It is a signal of intent from Alex McLeish that he believes that the club will stay in the Premier League or he would not want to sign new players for the new season if he did not know which division they were playing in. Although he is not the biggest name in world football and he may not excite the Villa fans as much as a few other names that are usually thrown around in the summer, Holman is a very consistent player and always chips in with goals and assists.

This season could prove to be his best yet in Holland with him already scoring six goals and contributing another nine assists. He has played in Holland for quite a long time now and was originally brought over by Feyenoord but did not play a game for the club and was loaned out to Excelsior where he finally started to make an impact, although this was in the second tier, he was starting to make a name for himself. He then continued to progress when he joined NEC Nijmegen, scoring 15 goals in the two seasons he was at the club which is pretty good for a winger.

He is currently at AZ Alkmaar and won the league with them in 2009. Every season he has been at the club he has got better and better and they were trying to persuade him to stay for longer but the lure of English football was too strong for him. He also has 53 caps for Australia scoring eight goals.

Holman playing for Australia against Japan

Now the question is will he succeed in England? A lot of the players we see coming from Holland are strikers and they have had a mixed time of playing in English football. Starting with Ruud Van Nistelrooy who was fantastic and in my opinion if he had stayed at Manchester United for the rest of his career would have come close to becoming the all time top scorer in the Premier League. However, there have been some expensive flops, the one that springs to mind the most is Afonso Alves who scored 47 goals in just 39 games for Dutch team Heerenveen. He then joined Middlesbrough and was very poor only scoring 10 league goals in his two years at the club. In his defence when he first signed he did look very promising as he scored six goals in his first 11 league games but then faded away and was very poor afterwards.

Two others that have not exactly failed in England but haven’t exactly hit the heights are Dirk Kuyt and Luis Suarez. Both were fantastic goal scorers but know Kuyt is seen more as a wide player and gets his fair share from that position but not enough for a striker. Suarez has looked pretty good but yet again has not added the goals to his performances.

So it will be interesting to see how Holman adapts to the Premier League but he may not be the flamboyant player the fans wanted to see and definitely feels like an Alex McLeish signing. Someone that has a high work rate and will try and cover every blade of grass and maybe what Villa need is someone that is going to unlock a defence when the game is tight which has cost them a few times this season.