Stuart Pearce’s first England squad

So Stuart Pearce has selected his first and possibly only England squad and the main surprises are the inclusion of Frazier Campbell and Tom Cleverley.

He knows both these players well from their time in the under 21s and will obviously feel they have the potential to step up and make a big impact on the international stage. However, both these players are just coming back from injury and although they have performed quite well, particularly, Campbell it does show a lack of experience and quality from Pearce. Surely they won’t be 100% at the minute so what is the point of taking them just to sit on the bench or not even be included in the squad. Pearce did comment saying that Campbell was a very good squad player and was a big character in the dressing room when he was in the under 21 squad. If the caretaker England manager believes that he will have the same effect in the full squad then he is sadly mistaken because no offence to the Sunderland striker but there are better players than him in the squad and I cannot imagine high profile players will have much time for him if he tries to take control of the group. The experienced players like Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney will take control and tell him what is expected and he will have to listen to them whereas in the under 21s there will not be as many big characters so he could control the group.

So maybe he has got a few selections wrong but at least he has brought Micah Richards back into the squad as he has been the best right back in the league and should have been our right back for years. I don’t think we have looked solid in that position since Gary Neville retired and Richards should have filled his boots but Capello obviously didn’t fancy him and preferred playing Glen Johnson who looks good going forward but is a very average defender. In the midfield he has basically done what all England managers have done and selected who he is expected to with him leaving out exciting players like Alex Oxlade Chamberlain and leaving the inconsistent Theo Walcott in his side. However, he has dropped Frank Lampard which to most England fans should be a fantastic thing because he has never really performed when it mattered and has been terrible at big tournaments. Add this to the fact that when he plays Steven Gerrard also underperforms, you have to wonder why he hasn’t been dropped sooner, maybe Andre Villas Boas has done England a favour by leaving him out of the Chelsea side.

In attack he has probably chose the right options with Rooney, Bent, Sturridge and Welbeck as they are the most in form and should probably be the four that go to the Euros. It will be interesting to see if he plays two up front because he will have to consider what he will do in the first two games of the Euros when Rooney is suspended.

The most worrying part about the England squad is the goalkeepers, if Joe Hart gets injured, England are struggling, Robert Green and Scott Carson are good enough for the bench but in a big tournament I would not trust them. All in all Pearce has not done what we expected, I was hoping he would bring in a lot of youth but no he has stuck with the players that have failed over and over again.

Advertisements

Is Stuart Pearce the right man for England?

Stuart Pearce has been put in temporary charge of England but could he possibly be the man to lead the nation fulltime? He has been working in international football for a number of years now, albeit with the under 21s but this experience could be invaluable as everybody knows being an international manager is very different to being a club manager. Dealing with players is a big part of being a club manager but on the international stage you see them for two weeks then they disappear for a couple of months. Therefore you don’t get to see the players day in and day out, so that is why I believe some managers do not take to international management as well as others. Using Capello as an example, he has a phenomenal record as a club manager possibly because of his reputation as a disciplinarian but he couldn’t exactly stamp his authority on players because after they left they could go back to doing whatever they wanted.

So back to Pearce, who actually had his first role in management back in 1996 when he was caretaker at Nottingham Forest but that was only until the end of the season and there was nothing he could have done to have saved them from relegation although he did win manager of the month while he was in charge. This was very early in his career and this was shown by the fact that when he left Forest, he carried on his playing career with Newcastle United, West Ham United and Manchester City.

He got his next chance in club management at City and it started brightly with them almost qualifying for the Europa League but a missed penalty in the last minute cost them a place. Pearce was prepared to make a few bold decisions which included taking off an outfield player for a goalkeeper so David James could play upfront which was very strange to see but at least it shows that he doesn’t mind taking a risk when he needs to. At City it was the first time he was linked with the England job but was obviously not chosen because he lacked experience. City began to struggle and were involved in relegation battles which eventually led to Pearce being sacked in 2007.

Pearce was handed the under 21 job on a permanent basis and they have performed admirably reaching the semi final in 2007 losing out in an epic penalty shootout against Holland and getting to the final in 2009 but being destroyed by Germany 4-0. However, this German side was brilliant and many of the players actually played in the World Cup against the first team in South Africa and we all know how that ended. However in 2011, the team failed to even get out of their group, although they did secure a very good draw against eventual winners Spain.

So should the man once known as Psycho be the next permanent manager of England? Of course he has the passion and the determination to succeed but sometimes you need more than that and his record so far does not suggest he will win a major tournament. However, if he was to be appointed, England would be copying Germany, with them hiring Joachim Low the former assistant to Jurgen Klinsmann and this has worked out very well for them. So who knows maybe he will bring back the passion and desire to succeed for the national team because at times it has looked like the players are not motivated to play for their country so at least under Pearce there would be no fear of that.