Who will be the next Chesterfield manager?

Chesterfield have sacked their manager John Sheridan after not winning any of their first three games in League 2.

To sack a manager this early in my opinion is a little crazy but now there have been two sacked already, (Andy Thorn at Coventry City) so maybe now you need a quick start to the season to keep your job especially if you are expected to be one of the favourites for promotion. But, I think they need to take a step back and it may be clichéd but the Football League is a marathon and not a sprint, you cannot get promoted in the first three games and certainly can’t get relegated. John Sheridan must have split opinion because he did very well at times by winning them the League 2 title in the 2010-11 season and then followed that up with the Football League Trophy the season after, but in League 1 they struggled and were rightfully relegated because they just weren’t good enough. Now, was that because of Sheridan’s tactics or something else? He had a decent record as manager winning 63 of his 163 games in charge which gives him a 39.38% win record so I fully expected them to be up there come the end of the season. Tommy Wright and Mark Crossley have been placed in temporary charge.

First name to put forward for the job permanently is Brian Laws who has been quite successful in Yorkshire before when he was manager of Sheffield Wednesday so at least he knows the area and it won’t take him long to settle down and can focus on the job straight from the off. He has also gained two promotions from League 2 in his career, both at Scunthorpe United, so he knows exactly what is needed in the division. Plus, he has Premier League experience and there may not be a lot of them linked with the job so he could have a few contacts to call upon to bring in decent players.

Next, is a manager that I feel was harshly sacked at his last club and that is Sean Dyche. He led unfancied Watford to 11th in the Championship last season and they looked very good under him, playing good football and on the whole looking very solid. Dyche, had to work on a small budget an use a lot of the youth players so this would also be beneficial to Chesterfield. Also, the icing on the cake and what makes him favourite for the job in my mind is the fact he started his career at the club and played 231 league games for them scoring eight goals. I’m sure he would be a fans favourite and popular choice.

Finally, another manager that has links to Yorkshire, Mark Robins, who has managed both Rotherham United and Barnsley. This would be an interesting choice because of the rivalry between Rotherham and Chesterfield but he has been successful in this division before and performed admirably at Rotherham when they were going through quite a turbulent time, starting one season with a 17 point deduction. His time at Barnsley didn’t go as well but he still achieved their targets and kept them in the Championship and only left because of differences with the board so he may even still be there now if they could have worked it out.

Advertisements

Who will be Coventry City’s next manager?

After three draws out of three and throwing away a two goal lead at home Coventry City have sacked their manager Andy Thorn.

I was a little shocked by this as they have made an ok start to the new season and it is a long season which means that the club can still battle for promotion. Just looking at the table, it is more than likely that the table will not end this way with Yeovil Town top after the first three games when they were expected to struggle all season (obviously they could still end up getting relegated). Thorn, hasn’t had a great time at Coventry with the club being relegated from the Championship last season but surely it is too early to sack a manager. They gave him the summer to get a squad together and now they haven’t even given him till the end of August to get them to play the way he wants. Only winning 13 of his 60 games in charge is not good enough but there have been a lot of other issues surrounding the club and he has had very little to work with. I honestly thought they would give him time because there are a lot of young players there and they need stability to get the best out of them.

Lee Carsley and Richard Shaw have been put in temporary charge and they will be given the opportunity to impress the board over the next few games and get the job permanently if they want it. But, I am going to focus on options outside of the club.

Now, I am going to put someone forward for nearly every job going until he gets a new one because he has been out of football for far too long and has been a success nearly everywhere he has been. And that man is Billy Davies. He has been out of work since June 2011 and maybe he hasn’t found the right job to take but I think he should put himself forward for this one as Coventry are a big club and their fans deserve the good times back. He will get them more attacking and all of his teams challenge near the top of the league so it will also help with attendances so it will be a win win situation for the board.

They could however, go in a different direction and appoint an up and coming manager in someone like Dean Holdsworth. Who has been doing a very good job at Aldershot Town. They haven’t had a great start to the season, only winning one game out of three but they only have a small budget and he has done well keeping them in League 2. For me, it would be too much of a step up but he is considered as one of the favourites so maybe the board like the fact that he can achieve his goals within a budget.

Finally, a surprising choice, would be a player that ended his career at the Ricoh Arena and scored 6 goals in 13 games for the club back in the 2005-06 season is Dennis Wise. He has been out of the management game for a long time with his last job being at Leeds United in 2008. He isn’t the most liked person in the world so I don’t know how the Coventry fans would react but he does have a decent record as manager and if he performs as well as he did as a player at the club then it would be a good move by the board. Personally, I hope he doesn’t get the job but there is no doubt his team will play with a lot of fight and determination which maybe exactly what the club needs.

Who will be Gillingham’s next manager?

Andy Hessenthaler has agreed to join the board of directors after stepping down from his post as manager of Gillingham.

Gillingham picked up 70 points from their 46 games

One of his first tasks will be to find a manager to lead the club back into League 1 which he unfortunately failed to do. They only finished one place and two points off the playoffs but this was deemed a failure because the club were expecting to get promoted this season. But if they can keep hold of most of their players they do have a squad good enough to achieve their ambitions in particular I think if Danny Kedwell stays then he can score a lot of goals and win them a lot of games.

So choosing a new manager with similar ambitions is vital and the favourite for the job is Martin Allen who will get the respect of the players and is arguably too good to be a manager in League 2 anyway but that is where he finds himself as he is currently the manager of Barnet where he is in is third spell. He kept them up this season with an impressive two wins out of three and as his past shows he doesn’t mind leaving clubs, especially Barnet, after only a few games. In his second spell as manager he was only in charge for three games. In my opinion he would be a good choice as all through his career he has won a lot of games and makes his teams difficult to beat. However, a word of caution would be that if a better opportunity comes up he will leave, no matter what position his club are in.

The man who Allen replaced at Barnet is also linked with the role. Lawrie Sanchez, the former Northern Ireland manager has had an interesting managerial career and I think he believes he is a lot better than what he actually is. Yes he did well with Northern Ireland and achieved a lot when there were such low expectations on the team but looking at the rest of his career, he has been average at best. At Fulham, he only won four of his 24 games in charge. At Barnet he probably was going to keep them up anyway and was harshly sacked by the board but they struggled all season and you can defend him and maybe say he didn’t have the players or the funds but only winning 15 of his games out of 53 is not good enough. So why should he get given the job of a team that is going for promotion?

Finally, Paul Ince should be in with a shout for the job because even though his career got damaged slightly by his time at Blackburn Rovers, he has achieved some good things in the lower leagues and maybe tried to go to the Premier League too quickly. He saved Macclesfield Town from relegation after they looked dead and buried winning 14 of his 35 games in charge. It was a remarkable effort and shows that he can do a good job in League 2. Add this to the fact that he won League 2 with MK Dons and I think Ince deserves another shot at League 2 and could bring glory to Gillingham. After Blackburn, his second spell at MK Dons and Notts County were solid but not very spectacular and he was doing a good job for both in my opinion.

I would like to see Paul Ince get the job and hopefully get Gillingham promoted because the club deserve to be in a higher division and he deserves to manage at a higher division so it could be a match made in heaven.